Offering plenty of support from their 2-in-1 design, the Brooks Sherpa 5-inch short is a comfortable choice for longer miles…

For the full roundup, check out the best 5-inch shorts

Brooks Sherpa 5-inch 2-in-1 Short


$72 / £55,


  • Wide, flat waistband
  • Good storage


  • Heavier than some

Comfort: 5/5
Support: 4.5/5
Sweat-wicking: 4/5
OVERALL: 4.5/5

A longer, 5-inch version of Brooks classic race-fit 3-inch Sherpa split shorts, these 2-in-1 shorts pair the same silky, lightweight four-way stretchy shell outer with a perforated inner short that drops lower down the leg. 

Brooks Sherpa 5-inch 2-in-1 Short features

A bit more like a twin trail short, these soft, comfortable, sweat-wicking liners have flat seams that are friendly to your delicates. Hundreds of perforations also help keep things airy and cool down there. 

The hybrid design really ramps up the versatility, too. You get the best of both worlds in shorts that hang light, loose and racy but offer a bit more coverage and comfort, ideal for longer training miles and post-run cafe stops. 

For out-and-out speed, check out the best 3-inch shorts for fast running

If you like a wider waistband that puts far less pressure on your paunch, these have the biggest on test. It also has a pleasantly soft lining and oversized drawcords make it easy to tweak the fit or to tie even with gloves.  

Want more support? These are the best 7-inch inseam shorts

Storage is good with two identical large drop-in rear mesh pockets just below the waistband. Both will hold a large smartphone, or if you run without your phone there’s room for four or five gels plus some other small running essentials.

Looking for gym shorts? These are the best shorts for men

However, stashed items don’t sit entirely bounce-free when you’re moving at full pelt, and because they’re open pockets, there’s a risk that things can spill out. One does have a handy elastic loop for securing keys, though, and there’s naother smartphone-size zippered pocket more security.

The Brooks Sherpa 5-inch shorts come in eight colours and prints and six sizes from XS to XXL.